The God Valley Incident Mirrors Real History: Saint Garling Based on a U.S. Indian Wars General

スポンサーリンク

Favorite Musicians in ONE PIECE

マイケルジャクソン ジャンゴ ムーンウォーク
出典:ONE PIECE 3巻 尾田 栄一郎

Jango’s moonwalk, Brook’s 45-degree “Zero Gravity” gag—
both of these tricks are directly inspired by Michael Jackson.

ブルック 40度 ゼログラビティ マイケルジャクソン
出典:ONE PIECE 61巻 尾田 栄一郎
マイケルジャクソン ゼログラビティ
出典:https://hypebeast.com/jp

And just like how Vegapunk’s name and Shaka’s design reference Daft Punk, Oda often borrows from musicians he admires.

So what if the Gorosei, who many fans thought were modeled on planets, were actually inspired by musicians instead?

Let’s take a look.

Jerry Garcia

ジェイガルシアサターン聖 五老星
出典:ONE PIECE 1073話 尾田 栄一郎/集英社
ジェリーガルシア 五老星
出典:https://monterreyrock.com/

Jaygarcia Saturn may be modeled after Jerome John “Jerry” Garcia, guitarist of the American rock band Grateful Dead.

The resemblance is both in name and appearance. And if you translate the band’s name literally—“Grateful Dead”—doesn’t that sound fitting? The Gorosei look like the undead, preserved by Imu’s powers:

サターン聖 イム様 人魚
出典:ONE PIECE 1125話 尾田 栄一郎/集英社

The “great dead” forced into immortality and displayed as rulers of the world… That’s basically the Grateful Dead.

Even the Grand Line (偉大なる航路) may echo the band’s name.

Their skull logo feels like a pirate flag, too.

And in the MV for their song “Touch of Grey”, the band members play as skeletons. Sound familiar? That’s Brook.

Bruno Mars

五老星 名前 英語版
出典:ONE PIECE 1086話 尾田 栄一郎/集英社
ブルーノマーズ 五老星
出典:https://www.hipjpn.co.jp/live/brunomars/

Marcus Mars could be named after Bruno Mars.

Real name: Peter Gene Hernandez.

He doesn’t look the same, but notice—his name has both Mars and Peter.

And Bruno Mars first broke out as a Michael Jackson impersonator. His stage outfits are famously MJ-inspired:

ブルーノ マイケル
出典:https://www.pinterest.jp/

As mentioned earlier, Oda is clearly a huge Michael Jackson fan. So it makes sense he’d also be fond of Bruno Mars, the superstar who rose by channeling MJ.

Freddie Mercury

フレディマーキュリー クイーン
出典:https://www.dr.dk/

Topman “Worcury” could be modeled on Freddie Mercury, the legendary vocalist of Queen.

We already know Oda loves Freddie—just look at Ivankov.

イワンコフ
出典:ONE PIECE 55巻 尾田 栄一郎

His stage outfits and mic work are lifted straight from the We Are the Champions MV:

NAS

ナズ 五老星
出典:https://jpstreet.jp/

Ethanbaron V. Nasjuro may be modeled on NAS, the American hip-hop MC.

Real name: Nasir bin Olu Dara Jones.

His debut album Illmatic (1994) is considered one of the greatest in hip-hop history, praised for its lyrical mastery and raw street reality.

NAS is known for socially conscious lyrics, addressing identity, inequality, and politics.

His album I Am… (which includes Nas Is Like) even has a cover reminiscent of Alabasta:

ナズ nas 五老星
出典:https://www.amazon.co.jp/

Sheppard

シェパード 五老星の名前
出典:Wikipedia

Sheppard Ju Peter may be named after Sheppard, an indie pop band from Australia.

Their hit “Geronimo” depicts militia creating human-like weapons clashing with soldiers. The song celebrates chasing dreams boldly, with “Geronimo” symbolizing daring action. Doesn’t that sound very One Piece-like?

And of course, Geronimo is the most famous Native American name.

Oda respects the Kinnikuman manga by Yudetamago, which also features a character named Geronimo.

スポンサーリンク

Native American History

ジェロニモ
出典:Wikipedia

Remember Miss Monday from Whiskey Peak? She might be based on Geronimo as well.

Whiskey Peak was modeled on Taos Pueblo, New Mexico. In real history, Taos was the site of Native American uprisings against white settlers.

Miss Monday, with her darker skin, standing up to Mr.5 in Baroque Works, echoes that. Her hairstyle and gun even resemble Geronimo’s.

Mr.9 ミスマンデー 結婚 子供
出典:ONE PIECE 64巻 尾田 栄一郎

Dark skin as a symbol of indigenous people:

翼族角色「金古」以神祕種族身份現身的戰鬥場面 キング ルナーリア
出典:ONE PIECE 102巻 尾田 栄一郎

And King too—also dark-skinned—was worth a 100M bounty just for being reported to the government. He may be one of the original inhabitants of the Red Line, survivors of the “land of the gods” Whitebeard once spoke of.

To the Celestial Dragons who call themselves gods, such people are the very ones they want erased from history.

This fits the broader theme of One Piece: real history, especially the Age of Exploration and white colonial invasions across the world.

The God Valley Incident itself seems modeled on American history—the massacre and hunting of Native peoples.

スポンサーリンク

The God Valley Incident and Saint Garling

ゴッドバレー事件 ロックス ロジャー
出典:ONE PIECE 108巻 尾田 栄一郎

God Valley = Valley of the Gods, Utah, a sacred site for Native Americans.

バレー・オブ・ザ・ゴッド ユタ州 ゴッドバレー
出典:Wikipedia

In the American frontier era, white settlers did not treat Native Americans as human, massacring them and taking their land.

Wars with Native Americans broke out all over the continent.

So the God Valley Incident can be seen as a direct parallel to the Indian Wars.

One figure in particular seems to be the model for Figarland Garling:

ガーリング聖 シャンクスそっくり
出典:ONE PIECE 1095話 尾田 栄一郎/集英社

Ernest Albert Garlington, a U.S. Army officer awarded the Medal of Honor for his role in the Wounded Knee Massacre.

Garlington → Garling. The name is strikingly close.

It seems likely that Garling is based on him.

アーネスト・アルバート・ガーリントン ガーリング聖 フィガーランド
出典:Wikipedia
スポンサーリンク

English One Piece theories

Want more? Check out our full collection of English One Piece articles here.

Related Articles
Vegapunk and Daft Punk →
https://yasaoblog.fun/onepiece/model/vegapunk-satellites

タイトルとURLをコピーしました