One Piece Chapter 1198 “The Island of Monsters” | Is the Black Monkey Luffy? The Nightmare Luffy Return Theory

Chapter 1198 “The Island of Monsters” Analysis

The angle of Sanji’s Conqueror’s Haki-infused kick that shattered Omen’s armor was a self-homage to the moment he landed a hit on the face of “Iron Wall” Pearl of the Krieg Pirates.

Sanji becomes a shield with Conqueror's Haki
Sanji and Pearl, the shield man

His declaration that he will not take another single hit, and his declaration that he will be Luffy’s “shield”.

And the burning body.

The answer Sanji arrived at was Pearl.

Pearl, the iron-wall shield man
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 7, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

Echoes of Drum Kingdom in Loki

Loki in hybrid form
Source: ONE PIECE, chapter 1198, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

We finally got to see Loki’s hybrid form, but honestly, I didn’t think it looked all that cool.

The explanatory frame said “Second Hybrid Form”, a mysterious phrase, so let’s look forward to the “first” form.

Also, I had been calling it the beast-man form until now, but it’s actually called the “hybrid form” in Japanese (人獣型). I wonder if I can fix my past posts…

Anyway, back to the Second Hybrid Form. The reason it doesn’t look cool to me is that it resembles characters who showed up in the past as the ones who get beaten.

It can’t be helped since it is the same Ryu Ryu no Mi, but he looks especially like Drake: the belt, the leather outfit, the way the area around the eyes is covered.

Getting defeated by an enemy in white clothes with a mask-like face is similar too.

Drake, Ryu Ryu no Mi
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 103, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

Another one that came to mind is Dalton.

  • A character who gets beaten
  • A Zoan type
  • Defeated by an enemy with a mask-like face

Those conditions are all met.

Dalton
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 15, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

Putting his body on the line to protect the people is similar too, and so is his inner nature.

Should we take this as preparation for Chopper’s awakening?

Nika, Turned Into a Monkey

Nika, pitch black with a tail
Source: ONE PIECE, chapter 1198, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

What appeared before Sanji was:

  • A pitch-black body
  • A tail
  • The Devil Fruit pattern from the shoulders to the back
  • A beast-like nose and fangs
  • A monkey-like cry of “Ukiki!”

It was Nika, who appears to have had his ego taken over by the Zoan fruit.

Incidentally, the scene of him lying on a tree branch, together with

Sanji and Brûlée resting in a tree
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 83, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

Beast Luffy is also a homage to the Whole Cake Island arc.

Beast Luffy
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 86, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

It Is Also a Homage to the Fight With Don Krieg

At the start, I explained that the kick to Killingham is a homage to Pearl, “Iron Wall” of the Krieg Pirates.

Monkey Luffy was also drawn in the fight against Don Krieg.

Monkey Luffy in the fight against Krieg
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 7, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

The scene where he goes wild grabbing the Rain God’s arm

is, I think, a self-homage to this panel ↓

Nika grabbing the Rain God's arm
Source: ONE PIECE, chapter 1198, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha
Monkey Luffy awakening
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 7, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

Cover Page Analysis

Chapter cover page: Brûlée gives Pudding three-lens glasses
Source: ONE PIECE, chapter 1198, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

Cover page request: “Brûlée presenting Pudding with glasses that have three lenses”

The main story goes like this…

Pearl, the Krieg Pirates’ “Iron Wall” → Luffy turning into a monkey in the Krieg fight → Monkey and Luffy fusing on Whole Cake Island → that time he used Brûlée’s ability

Brûlée
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 86, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

→ Carrot calls Brûlée a tree and Luffy calls her a branch. Those nicknames suggest a visual parallel.

Brûlée, whom Luffy calls a branch
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 83, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

→ Speaking of creatures that fused tree and human, there is the “tree old man” Luffy tried to recruit at Thriller Bark

Cerberus and the tree old man
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 46, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

→ When recruiting the tree old man, he was riding a three-headed Cerberus

So Brûlée is the “tree old man”, and Pudding with her third eye is the “three-headed Cerberus”.

In other words, it is a cover illustration inspired by a Thriller Bark homage.

Could Black Nika Echo Nightmare Luffy?

The reason the cover page pays homage to Thriller Bark is that Luffy, whose ego was taken by a Zoan Devil Fruit, is a homage to Nightmare Luffy from Thriller Bark.

Nightmare Luffy
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 49, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

As for what comes next, I think they are going to recreate Oars with Luffy’s shadow inside vs. the Straw Hats using Nika, rampaging after his ego was taken by a Devil Fruit, vs. the Straw Hats.

Oars and the Straw Hats
Source: ONE PIECE, vol. 50, Eiichiro Oda / Shueisha

By the way, I predicted this Nika rampage on X back in July. (Post from July 14, 2026)

In the July 14 post, I suggested that if Luffy lost consciousness, the Zoan fruit might take over, leading to a rampage like Elbaf’s god of destruction. Original post on X.

Read in another language · 日本語 · Español · Deutsch · Français · Português · Italiano · 繁體中文

Scroll to Top